Tribology

Tribology of Bearing Surfaces

Polyethylene

Chemistry

  • The basic monomer is C2H4.
  • Polymerized into a repeating chain by addition polymerization to give high-density polyethylene (HDP).
  • Free radicals are produced which attach to the carbon atom and then join to each other, creating a continuous chain.
  • Adjacent chains are held by weak van der Waals forces.

How Can Strength Be Increased?

  • Increasing Molecular Weight: Higher molecular weight results in more chains.
  • Creating Cross-links: Cross-linking between chains increases strength.
  • Reducing Crystallinity: A lower crystallinity enhances flexibility and strength.

Polyethylene Architecture

  • Differing structural areas within polyethylene:
    • Crystalline: Organized 3-dimensional patterns of chains.
    • Amorphous: Random entanglement of chains with a propensity for cross-linking.
  • Longer chains lead to a greater proportion of the amorphous area.
  • A greater amorphous area results in greater strength and wear resistance, forming the basis for UHMWPE (Ultra High Molecular Weight Polyethylene).
  • Characteristics of UHMWPE:
    • Increased chain length.
    • Increased number of chains.
    • Increased proportion of amorphous areas.

Cross-linking, Sterilization, and Storage of Polyethylene

  • Sterilization traditionally done by gamma irradiation in air.
  • Radiation encourages cross-linking between polyethylene chains, improving wear rates and tensile strength.
  • Irradiation generates free radicals that form cross-links, but:
    • In the presence of oxygen, free radicals oxidize and degrade polyethylene.
    • Oxidation reduces wear properties and occurs mainly in the subsurface white band (1-2mm).
    • Over time, this layer increases in size, allowing further oxidation.
  • Oxidation occurs if:
    • Polyethylene is sterilized in air or oxygen.
    • Oxygen seeps into packaging over time (shelf life > 2 years).
  • Better Sterilization Methods:
    • Gamma irradiation in inert gas (argon or nitrogen) or in a vacuum.
    • Sterilization using gas plasma or ethylene oxide (no radiation, no oxygen).

Highly Cross-linked UHMWPE

  • Made by prolonged irradiation for even more cross-linking.
  • In vitro shows better wear rates than UHMPE.
  • However, increased cross-linking can lead to:
    • Reduced fatigue resistance.
    • Reduced fracture toughness.
  • Caution is advised regarding the use of highly cross-linked polyethylene, especially in total knee replacements (TKR), as failure often results from fatigue fractures rather than wear.

Polyethylene Manufacturing

  • Traditional Method: RAM Bar extrusion, where a cylindrical ‘bar’ of polyethylene is machined into individual implants (especially for TKR).
  • Issues with RAM Bar Extrusion:
    • Properties of produced implants differ according to their location within the bar.
  • Solutions:
    • Calcium stearate is added to prevent yellowing and corrosion but may lead to fusion defects and worse wear properties.
  • Other Manufacturing Options:
    • Compression molding followed by machining.
    • Direct compression molding (DCM) is considered the gold standard.
    • In DCM, polyethylene powder is directly compressed into a mold without further machining or additives, allowing for further irradiation in inert gas to promote cross-linking, resulting in optimal wear rates.

Ceramics

Types Used in Orthopaedics

  • Zirconia: Not used anymore due to high fracture rates and cost.
  • Alumina: Main ceramic used, improved quality compared to the first generation.
  • Oxinium: Oxidized zirconia.
  • Hydroxyapatite: Osteoconductive ceramic that aids in bone growth and bonding but can shear off implants and is difficult to coat.

Manufacturing

  • Produced by pressing ceramic powder and water into a pre-fabricated cast.
  • Sintering (heating) is then done to increase density, but over-sintering leads to porosity and weakens the ceramic.
  • Strength Dependence: Strength is dependent on the original grain size; smaller grain size results in stronger ceramic.

Material Properties

  • Hard: Third hardest material known.
  • Stiff: High modulus of elasticity.
  • Inert: Particles are not biologically active.
  • Low Surface Roughness: Smooth, reducing abrasive wear of polyethylene.
  • Good Scratch Profile: Less scratching leads to reduced wear.
  • Wettable: Better lubrication properties.
  • Low Wear Characteristics:
    • Less linear wear.
    • Less osteolysis due to smaller, less active particles.

Limitations

  • Brittle: Virtually no plastic deformation before failure, posing a risk of fracture.
  • Long-term Data: Not yet available.
  • Cost: More expensive than alternatives.
  • Squeaking: May be caused by positioning or aging ceramics.

Oxidized Zirconium

  • A metallic alloy of zirconium with a ceramic surface.
  • Oxidation in air converts the surface into ceramic, making it part of the material, not just a coating.
  • Provides properties similar to ceramics: hard, smooth, scratch-resistant, inert, and wettable.
  • Suitable for metal allergies due to low nickel content.
  • In vitro studies show greatly reduced polyethylene wear, but no long-term in vivo trials yet.

Ceramic Fracture

  • Presence of third-body wear leads to plastic and particulate debris.
  • Revision should include synovectomy to remove all ceramic debris.
  • Damage to the Morse taper may necessitate revision to prevent catastrophic failure.
  • Ceramic particulate debris is typically not biologically active due to its small size, but third-body wear can produce more active debris.

Metal on Metal (MoM) Articulations

  • Historical Issues: Equatorial bearing had high frictional torque, jamming, and high failure rates.
  • Current Design: Polar bearing with much lower frictional torque; requires a cup head clearance of 90-200 micrometers.
  • Main Properties of MoM:
    • Fracture toughness.
    • Hardness.
    • Low roughness (smooth and polished).
    • Small particle generation leads to low biological activity (50-100 nm).
    • Self-healing capabilities; small scratches are polished out with articulation.
    • Very resistant to abrasive wear.
    • Osteolysis is not a major concern.

Challenges

  • Produce a greater number of particles, particularly during the initial two years (bedding-in period).
  • Wear Mode: Primarily adhesive, which can be mitigated by using alloys with greater carbide content (e.g., adding molybdenum).

Lubrication in MoM

  • Fluid film lubrication exists in MoM bearings, but problems include:
    • Metal ion dissemination into the bloodstream.
    • Potential carcinogenesis risks.
    • Occurrence of metallosis, leading to adverse local tissue reactions (ALVAL) and pseudotumors.
  • MoM total hip replacements (THR) with large heads may experience wear at the taper due to size mismatch.
Back to top